Prometheus is full of grandeur and wonder, but thematically over reaches…

A female figure in silhouette stands before an enormous statue of a humanoid head. Text at the middle of the poster reveals the tagline "The Search For Our Beginning Could Lead To Our End". Text at the bottom of the poster reveals the title, production credits and rating.

Shame really, because it’s beautifully structured and could have been a solid sci-fi, horror film…maybe even a classic.  But, alas.  Despite brilliant visuals, seamless special effects and some strong acting, I was left wanting. I was entertained and captivated by the narrative, but by the third act it strays and so did my interest.  Too much dogma and too many unanswered (important) questions.  I still do not want to give too much away, so here is a brief breakdown.

A few things to know first.  1. I respect Sir Ridley Scott and most of his films.  2. I believe Alien is one of the best sci-fi films of all time.  3. I was very excited about Prometheus.  So excited, that I refused to watch any of the viral campaign because I did not want to spoil anything (I think that may have helped little) and stayed away from reviews!  So, I went in with a clear, eager mind.

Several notable aspects that must be mentioned.  1. The film is gorgeous. Cinematographer Dariusz Wolski does a wonderful job with the look and style.  2. Amazing sets, creatures and cool future tech equals a geek’s dream. 3. There is a top-notch cast across the board. Stand outs?  Noomi Rapace is fantastic and Michael Fassbender is (again) incredible.  4. Scott is a master of building tension (the slow burn) and he does create a specific “atmosphere” that is mesmerizing.

Several negative aspects that must be mentioned.  1. Too many things that make you go…hmmm? or whaaa?  2. Events pick up speed (and violence) in the third act and makes it feel rushed, especially since it’s a stark contrast with the first half.  3. The “Big” themes feel forced and too broad.  4.  Damon Lindelof thinks he’s still writing for a Lost episode.  5.  Lindelof and Scott must think answers are taboo and should be avoided–actually they just keep asking questions…

All in all, in some aspects I think Prometheus succeeds brilliantly.  How?  Well, Prometheus will probably be the most divisive film of 2012 and will stir debates and discussions for years to come (more so, if the rumored sequel does happen).  Isn’t that what you want a film to do?  You want to promote dialogue and engage the imagination, right?  Well…only you can answer that question.


About nediunedited

Who is nediunedited? A lover of cinema since the age of seven! All kinds–all genres. Films (TV and Books, too) have shaped my life–they were my escape, my inspiration and even my first role models. I do not rate my films in the traditional sense (no stars, grades, etc.)–instead I give you my opinion and my take on it–I do not give traditional plot summaries either, because I want you to go in clear–ready for your own experience. There is nothing better than discovering a fine film, without any other influence. (Personally, when I want to really see something I practice media shut out–I refuse to watch too many trailers, viral promos, reviews, etc–I have been known to cover my eyes and ears in the theater during trailers–LALALALA!) That’s me–hope you come by and visit! I will definitely make the rounds and find some of you out there, too.

4 thoughts on “Prometheus is full of grandeur and wonder, but thematically over reaches…

  1. Yeah I mostly agree… lot of fun, great cast but I think what you say about Lindelof is particularly true. Certainly left me scratching my head a bit and not quite for all the right reasons!

  2. Nice even handed review Nedi, despite all it’s flaws, particularly having to do with the Script I enjoyed seeing the film. It’s a testament to the direction of Scott and the performances of the the cast that this turned out as well as it did.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s